San Diego Reiki​ 858-333-5988
  • About
    • What is Reiki?
    • About Dr. Danilychev
    • FAQ
  • REIKI SESSIONS
  • Classes
  • CONTACT
    • Help
  • BLOG

What about Reiki for animals? Could it be a Placebo?

4/1/2018

0 Comments

 
In general, placebo effect is a human phenomenon. It is observed when a person perceives an improvement due to his or her expectation of positive effect of a specific treatment. 

Every healing modality for humans has some degree of placebo effect. Placebo effect can range widely, from a few % up to about 30%, and the degree of placebo effect depends on multiple factors. 

When it relates to humans, the real question is whether or not the specific treatment is more effective than a placebo. The only way to answer that question, is to conduct a placebo-controlled clinical trial, comparing a specific treatment for a specific problem to a placebo. A large number of people participating in the study is usually needed in order to determine whether or not the difference between the improvement in the placebo and the treatment group is statistically significant. If there is a statistically significant difference in a series of well-designed studies, then we can conclude that the effect of a specific treatment for a specific problem is real, and that it is not just due to a placebo effect. Until this extensive research is completed, we cannot make that determination.

Note, in my case, it was through decade-long observation of Reiki, Healing Touch and Acupuncture being effective for hundreds and hundreds of patients, that I could see that those modalities was effective significantly above 30%. It was only through that extensive observational evidence (and my neutrality towards the final answer) that I was able to come to a scientific conclusion that Alternative Medicine modalities such as Reiki, Healing Touch and Acupuncture can be effective beyond the placebo effect. With that said, it was my conclusion and my conclusion only, which has not been adequately tested by well-designed placebo-controlled clinical trials (at least in case of Reiki and Healing Touch). This means that although I am convinced that Reiki can be very helpful, and helpful beyond the placebo effect, it is by no means a scientific fact, since it has not yet been proven by scientific studies.

When it comes to animals, the placebo effect has not been adequately studied. I would expect, that those animals who can sense a caring human approach would be a subject to a placebo effect. It is not uncommon to see what's called a "caring nurse" phenomenon in human studies. This phenomenon is observed when the clinical research center staff is behaving in a caring way towards research participants, which significantly increases the placebo effect, often to the point, that it is impossible to demonstrate a statistically significant difference even between the treatment that is already known to be effective and placebo. I can imagine that with animals such as cats, dogs, horses, certain birds, etc., we can observe a similar phenomenon, where the effect of a caring healer would increase the degree of a placebo effect of an energy treatment. So just like with humans, the only way to scientifically demonstrate that a healing modality is more effective than a placebo for animals, is to conduct a series of well-designed studies, and specifically studies that take the "caring healer" phenomenon into account. There is no other way to answer that question.

On a different note, people don't utilize energy medicine for themselves or for their pets because it has been scientifically proven to work (it hasn't been), but because they have either heard good things about it or have already experienced it with positive results themselves. So whether or not it is a placebo effect, if what you do it works, it works. :)
0 Comments



Leave a Reply.

    Author

    Dr. Maria Danilychev, MD is a hospice doctor, clinical research physician, and a Jikiden Reiki Shihan (master/teacher).

    Archives

    May 2019
    April 2019
    March 2019
    February 2019
    January 2019
    December 2018
    November 2018
    June 2018
    May 2018
    April 2018
    March 2018
    February 2018
    January 2018
    December 2017
    November 2017
    October 2017
    September 2017
    August 2017
    July 2017
    June 2017
    May 2017
    April 2017
    March 2017
    February 2017
    January 2017

    Categories

    All
    Benefits Vs. Harm
    Boundaries
    Chiyoko Yamaguchi
    Choosing Reiki Style
    Choosing Reiki Teacher
    Choosing The Right Class
    Consent
    Dedication
    Ethical
    Ethics
    Free Resources
    Gendai Reiki
    Gokai
    Hawayo Takata
    Hayashi Sensei
    Hiroshi Doi
    Holly Fire Reiki
    How To Start A Reiki Practice
    Hyakuten Inamoto
    Is Reiki Always Appropriate
    Japanese Reiki
    Jikiden Reiki
    Jikiden Reiki Institute
    Karuna Reiki
    Komyo Reiki
    Learning Reiki
    Medical Reiki
    Mikao Usui
    Misunderstandings In Reiki
    Nurses
    Nursing
    Okuden
    Patients' Autonomy
    Patients' Rights
    Patricia Lee
    Permission To Do Reiki
    Placebo
    Practicing Reiki
    Professionalism
    Reiki Ability
    Reiki And Law
    Reiki And Medicine
    Reiki And Science
    Reiki And Spirituality
    Reiki Benefits
    Reiki Books
    Reiki Classes
    Reiki Consent
    Reiki Effectiveness
    Reiki For Animals
    Reiki From The Medical Perspective
    Reiki History
    Reiki In Medicine
    Reiki In Nursing
    Reiki Is Amazing
    Reiki Is Nonsense
    Reiki Levels
    Reiki Lineage
    Reiki Master
    Reiki Meaning
    Reiki Practice
    Reiki Principles
    Reiki Research
    Reiki Resources
    Reiki Schools
    Reiki Styles
    Reiki Teacher
    Reiki Training
    Reiki Treatment
    Rika Tanaka
    Self Referral
    Shihan
    Shinpiden
    Shin Shin Kaizen Usui Reiki Ryoho
    Shoden
    Special People
    Starting A Reiki Practice
    Tibetan Reiki
    Traditional Reiki
    Usui
    Usui Reiki
    Usui Sensei
    Usui Shiki Ryoho
    What Is Reiki
    William Lee Rand

    RSS Feed

Just for today, don't get angry, don't worry, be grateful, do your best, be kind...
Privacy policy
  • About
    • What is Reiki?
    • About Dr. Danilychev
    • FAQ
  • REIKI SESSIONS
  • Classes
  • CONTACT
    • Help
  • BLOG